Architecture●●●●●Difficulty 3 of 5

Why did Gaudí design his churches upside down, with hanging strings?

Antoni Gaudí hung strings weighted with little bags of lead shot from a ceiling, photographed them, and turned the photo upside down. That was his church.

▶ Start the story

Gaudí hung his churches upside down because a hanging string finds the perfect arch by itself. A chain or rope that carries only its own weight settles into a curve called a catenary, and every part of it is pulled purely in tension. Flip that shape over and the pulls become pushes: an arch built along it is squeezed purely in compression, with no bending, exactly what stone and brick are good at. By hanging weighted strings from points marking his columns, Gaudí let gravity calculate shapes that would otherwise have taken endless equations.

The idea was old. In the 1670s Robert Hooke hid it in a Latin anagram, revealed after his death: 'As hangs a flexible cable so, inverted, stand the touching pieces of an arch.' Gaudí turned it into a design machine. For the church of the Colònia Güell near Barcelona, he hung hemp ropes loaded with little sacks of lead shot from a ceiling, at one-tenth scale, so the weights mimicked the real loads. Then he photographed the tangle, turned the photo upside down and painted the church over it.

Gaudí's upside-down design method
  1. Step 1: Plan on the ceiling

    Floor plan drawn on a board fixed overhead

  2. Step 2: Hang strings

    From the points where columns and corners stand

  3. Step 3: Add weights

    Bags of lead shot matching the real loads, at 1:10

  4. Step 4: Photograph

    The strings settle into catenaries

  5. Step 5: Flip it

    The inverted photo shows the arches and vaults

The pay-off was a building that needed no flying buttresses. Gaudí despised them: Gothic architecture, he said, was 'a defective body held up on crutches'. His catenary arches carried their weight down their own curves.

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.Why does an arch shaped like an inverted hanging chain stand so well?
  2. 2.Why did Gaudí load his hanging strings with bags of lead shot?
  3. 3.Why does the main cable of a suspension bridge with a flat roadway hang as a parabola, not a catenary?

Recap

Hang it, then flip it: a hanging chain is pure tension, and the same curve inverted is pure compression.

Surprising fact · The Gateway Arch in St. Louis isn't a true catenary but a 'weighted catenary', like a chain with lighter links in the middle.

Sources (5)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (27 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]Catenary · Wikipedia
  2. [2]Antoni Gaudí · Wikipedia
  3. [3]Gateway Arch · Wikipedia
  4. [4]Church of Colònia Güell · Wikipedia
  5. [5]Sagrada Família · Wikipedia
More lessons in 🏛️ Architecture (3) See all architecture lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗